Tian Tian vs Ah-Tai – Who Wins The Chicken Rice War?

Tian Tian Chicken Rice, known to be Singapore’s top chicken rice and featured on Anthony Bourdain’s programme No Reservations, had lost its ‘Master Chef’.

The man, better known as Ah Tai, who has been cooking the famed Tian Tian Chicken Rice set up another chicken rice shop just 3 stalls away at Maxwell. His stall has been attracting media fanfare and a longer queue during lunch. (I sense lots of drama because he is also a relative of Tian Tian’s boss Ms Loi Mui Yin who sacked him after a quarrel!)

So who wins the chicken rice war?

Firstly, Tian Tian’s winning formula to me has to be its rice. Even Anthony Bourdain said that the chicken rice is so fragrant and delicious that it can be eaten on its own. Probably one of the best chicken rice in Singapore, it’s warm, fluffy, fragrant and tasty. So good I can just eat it with the chilli sauce.

Ah Tai’s rice is very similar, too similar. It is served with a special sauce poured over, though I noticed the taste of the rice could be uneven at parts. Despite what many reviewers said, Tian Tian’s rice resonates better with me.

Both chickens are fresh, cold and succulent. Ah Tai’s chicken came boneless, and made eating a lot easier.

As Ah Tai staff was seeing me taking lots of photos of their food, I was immediately served a bowl of hot soup. Despite that, Ah Tai’s clear soup is very comfortable on the tummy, and felt ‘healthier’ and less salty.

Another must-have with my chicken rice is ‘tau gay’. Tian Tian’s bean sprouts were served hot with cut chillies and shallots – very crunchy, and tasty with the dash of chicken oil poured over.

Ah Tai’s sprouts lacked that same crunchiness. Though I must say their staff is very polite and tries to interact with you on a personal basis (compared to the systematic ‘cold’ queue at Tian Tian) – perhaps the cause of the longer waiting times as well.

Overall, both chicken rices are definitely delicious and it is almost hard to differentiate if you do a blind-taste test. After all, Ah-Tai cooked with Tian Tian for 20 years. If I were to pick one stall to eat from, it would still be Tian Tian. I know you may disagree with me.

Tian Tian Hainanese Chicken Rice
1 Kadayanallur Street, #01-10 Maxwell Food Centre, Singapore (Chinatown MRT Station) Tel: +65 9691 4852
Opening Hours: 11am – 8 Daily (Closed on Mons)

Ah-Tai Hainanese Chicken Rice
1 Kadayayanallur Street, #01-07 Maxwell Food Centre, Singapore (Chinatown MRT Station) Tel: +65 8137 6559
Opening Hours: 11am – 8pm Daily (or till sold out)

Other Related Entries
Loy Kee Chicken Rice (Balestier)
Beach Road Scissor Cut Curry Rice (Jalan Besar)
Sin Kee Chicken Rice (Margaret Drive)
Golden Mile Claypot Rice (Golden Mile)
Kay Lee Roast Meat Joint (Paya Lebar)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

6 Responses to “Tian Tian vs Ah-Tai – Who Wins The Chicken Rice War?”

  1. May 16, 2012 at 10:34 am #

    I’m off chicken for almost a month now, due to surgery. Your review came in at the right time cuz i might be able to eat chicken anytime soon! *Drools* at the first two photos!

    • admin
      May 16, 2012 at 10:41 am #

      You can eat both stalls now and tell me which you prefer! :D

  2. May 21, 2012 at 9:11 pm #

    Either way, this chicken rice war is going to be a win win situation for consumers (us)

  3. September 15, 2012 at 1:05 am #

    I don’t like ah tai chicken rice…its so overhyped and the rice is not even nice..the chili is damn spicy tho..hahahaha

    • admin
      September 16, 2012 at 2:03 pm #

      Compared to Tian Tian? I mean some of the old regulars preferred Ah Tai leh.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Singapore’s chicken rice war | This and That - September 26, 2014

    […] thriller. Places where you will read more about this side-line of the chicken rice war are here and here and here and […]

Leave a Reply